Welcome to Castle Hill Supper Club in Merrillan, Wisconsin - Famous for Steaks!
Appetizers
Dinner Menu
Nightly Specials
Grand Seafood Buffet
Dessert Menu
Banquets
History
Contact Us
Home
  We invite you to enjoy our tradition of quality food and cheerful, attentive service! Our dinner menu features many signature dishes that have had people coming back to Castle Hill Supper Club again and again. We hope you'll join them!

Please choose what you'd like to view:
   
 
 
 
All of our steaks are either USDA Prime or Choice cuts of Beef.
Char-broiled to your specifications.
King’s Filet Mignon
Castle Hill’s Cadillac of Steaks!. Hand cut Tenderloin wrapped in bacon and topped with our own special mushroom gravy. 8oz
Ribeye
A house favorite, For the Serious Steak Lover, Cut from the eye of the rib. 10oz
Prime Rib (Saturdays)
Our famous prime rib, hand selected and slow roasted to perfection. The Finest Prime Rib in town!! 12oz
Tenderloin
The ultimate in tenderness. Try it with our special mushroom gravy! 5oz
King’s Cut Prime Rib (Saturdays)
The same famous Prime Rib as above for the super appetite! 18oz
Bone In Ribeye
Our Mouthwatering 16oz USDA Choice Ribeye Steak with the bone left on for extra flavor! Charbroiled to your specifications.
Super Cut Prime Rib (Saturdays)
One Huge Cut of Beef that will feed a family of four. If this doesn’t fill you up, nothing will! 24oz
New York Strip
One of our finest cuts. Center cut from the loin
and aged to perfection. 12oz
Top Sirloin
Boneless, aged Sirloin of Iowa corn-fed beef. Our most popular cut. 8oz
King’s Top Sirloin
An even larger cut of our most popular steak, char-broiled to perfection! 16oz
HOW TO ORDER YOUR STEAKS
RARE – Cool, Red Center MEDIUM RARE - Warm, Red Center MEDIUM – Hot, Pink Center
MEDIUM WELL – Thin, Pink Center WELL DONE – Hot Brown Center
Not responsible for steaks done Medium Well & Well Done!
   
 
 
 
 
Shrimp (Batter Fried, Steamed, or Coconut)
Jumbo Black Tigers, hand-dipped in a delicate batter and served with our home-made cocktail sauce.
Shrimp Feast
Jumbo Black Tigers, hand-dipped in a delicate batter along with our Stuffed Shrimp with crab meat and Monterey Jack cheese & Coconut Shrimp.
Fish Boil (Fridays)
A Castle Hill tradition! Premium Center Cut Cod Fillets boiled in special herbs and spices with baby red potatoes & onions, and topped with butter and lemon.
Cod (Battered Fried or Baked)
Premium Center Cut Cod Fillets from the fishing fleet of the Arctic.
Walleye Pike (Deep Fried or Baked)
A fish lovers dream, light and flaky.
Stuffed Shrimp
Plump, stuffed with crab meat and Monterey Jack cheese.
Garlic Scallops
Sweet morsels from the deep sea. Sauteed in butter, garlic & herbs. Served with lemon & topped with our seasoned crumbs.
Lobster Cold Water - Two Tails
Steamed, savory and sweet, a true delicacy. Served with drawn butter & fresh lemon. The best in the world!
   
 
 
 
For the person who can’t decide…..a taste from both worlds!

• USDA Choice 8 oz. Top Sirloin Steak


with your choice of one of the following items:


• Shrimp
(Battered Fried, Steamed or   Coconut)
• Stuffed Shrimp
• Lobster
(One Tail)

Dinners include: Choice of Potato ( Jumbo Idaho Baked w/Real WI Sour Cream, American Fries, Crispy Battered French Fries, Potato Skins, Hash Browns) or Vegetable, Choice of Lettuce Salad or Coleslaw, Fresh Baked Kaiser Roll Basket & Relish Tray.

• Extra Plate Charge $3.00 (includes choice of potato)

With groups of 8 or more, a 18% Gratuity will be added to your bill.

   
 
 
 
Broasted Chicken
Tender, Juicy, Marinated flavors deep down to the bone. Pressure fried until golden brown.
It will make you forget all about the Colonel!
Chicken Fettuccini
Our legendary Chicken Fettuccini! Two boneless chicken breasts broiled, laid on a bed of fettuccini noodles and topped with our Scrumptious Alfredo sauce
Fettuccini Alfredo
Fettuccini noodles topped with our Scrumptious Alfredo sauce.
Barbecued Ribs
Tasty, meaty pork ribs, slow cooked till they fall off the bone. Then gently laced with our Sweet & Tangy BBQ sauce.
Pork Chops
Two 8 oz Center Cut Pork Chops Chargrilled to perfection!
Served with Applesauce.
   
 
 
 
Platter Includes French Fries & Coleslaw
Batter Fried Fish
Flaky Cod Fillet deep-fried in a delicate batter and served on a Grilled Kaiser Roll.
Chopped Sirloin Burger
Two - 1/3 pound Ground Sirloin Patties Char-broiled just the way you like it and served on a Grilled Kaiser Roll.
Char-grilled Chicken
Plump & Juicy, marinated Chicken Breast on a Grilled Kaiser Roll. Choose Plain, Cajun or BBQ!
Chicken Fingers
Juicy Chicken Tenders deep fried in a crunchy seasoned breading until golden brown & served with our Sweet & Tangy BBQ Sauce.
   
 
 
 
Tenderloin
The ultimate in tenderness. Try it with our special mushroom gravy! 5oz
Cod (Battered Fried or Baked)
Premium Center Cut Cod Fillets from the fishing fleet of the Arctic.
Chicken Fettuccini
Our legendary Chicken Fettuccini. Half the size of our regular portion!
Broasted Chicken
Tender, Juicy, Marinated flavors deep down to the bone. Pressure fried until golden brown.
It will make you forget all about the Colonel!
Pork Chop
8 oz Center Cut Pork Chop Chargrilled to perfection! Served with Applesauce
Shrimp (Batter Fried, Steamed, Stuffed or Coconut)
Jumbo Black Tigers, hand-dipped in a delicate batter.
   
 
 
 

  • Castle Hill’s Famous Mushroom Gravy
  • Buttered Mushrooms
  • Sauteed Onions
  • Lettuce Salad with choice of dressing
  • Choice of Potato
  • Home-Made Soup of the Day


  • Milk (2%, Skim or Chocolate)
  • Juice (Orange, Tomato, Grapefruit, Pineapple or Cran-raspberry)
  • Hot Chocolate
  • Cappuccino ( French Vanilla or
    Almond Amaretto)
  • Fresh Ground Coffee
  • Hot Tea, Ice Tea or Raspberry Ice Tea
  • Pink Lemonade

Soft Drinks (Free refills on Pepsi products!)
Pepsi - Diet Pepsi - Sierra Mist - Mountain Dew

   
 
   
 

Appetizers Dinner Menu Nightly Specials Grand Seafood Buffet
Dessert Menu Banquets History Contact Home
Castle Hill Supper Club - N9581 US Hwy 12, Merrillan, Wisconsin  54754 / For reservations call 715-333-5901
Web Design by EZ New Media